Question

Saying ‘Why Did Allah Create Relatives?’

219

Question

I wanted to ask if somebody says out of frustration, “why did Allah create relatives”, what's the ruling on the sentence?

Related Fatwa

Ruling on Giving a Copy of the Quran to a Disbeliever

Types of friendship with non-Muslims

She Sleeps in the Same Room with her Grandmother who Keeps Saying Kufr Words

Nullification of Marriage by Apostasy

Disliking the Opinion of a Scholar Is Not an Act of Disbelief

No Special Merit in Quran or the Sunnah for One Who Kills the Blasphemer of Prophet

Saying that Allah, His Prophets, and the Believers Are Disbelievers in Taaghut

Accepted Answer

All perfect praise be to Allah, The Lord of the Worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allah, and that Muhammad is His slave and Messenger.

Just uttering this expression is neither Kufr (disbelief) nor apostasy.

It may be just a question in order to know, and this is permissible. It may also be said as a way of resentment and discontent, while recognizing the extreme Wisdom of Allah, and this is forbidden.

Rather, this phrase is considered Kufr if it is said as a way of objection and aspersion to the Wisdom of Allah – and it is unlikely that a Muslim would say this.

Allah knows best.

Fatwa

Saying ‘Why Did Allah Create Relatives?’

Question

Answer

Related Fatwa

Ruling on Giving a Copy of the Quran to a Disbeliever

Types of friendship with non-Muslims

She Sleeps in the Same Room with her Grandmother who Keeps Saying Kufr Words

Nullification of Marriage by Apostasy

Disliking the Opinion of a Scholar Is Not an Act of Disbelief

No Special Merit in Quran or the Sunnah for One Who Kills the Blasphemer of Prophet

Saying that Allah, His Prophets, and the Believers Are Disbelievers in Taaghut

Search Fatwa

Fatwa Subject

Categories

Multimedia

Special Folders

Services