Whether Mawqoof hadeeth strengthens weak Marfoo‘ hadeeth

2-10-2017 | Islamweb

Question:
I was wondering, can a weak hadith be corroborated by Mawqoof (attributed to a Companion) narrations from the Companions? For example, what if they are about matters of the Unseen?

Answer:

All perfect praise be to Allah, the Lord of the worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allah and that Muhammad, , is His slave and Messenger.

First of all, we say that the authentic Mawqoof narrations about matters that are not subject to personal opinion and were reported from a Companion who was not known to relate from the Israelites take the ruling of Marfoo‘ narrations (those directly attributed to the Prophet, ) as stated by the scholars of Hadeeth. Please, refer to fatwa 337342.

This kind of Mawqoof hadeeth strengthens the weak hadeeth.

Abdullah ibn Yoosuf Al-Jadee’ wrote a chapter about strengthening the weak hadeeth with the Mawqoof hadeeth in his book Tahreer ‘Uloom Al-Hadeeth. He concluded that the Mawqoof hadeeth does not strengthen the Marfoo‘ hadeeth except if it is about a matter wherein there is no room for personal opinion and provided it is not one of the Israelite narrations.

Allah knows best.

www.islamweb.net