Question
I am asking about forbidding other people's children to commit evil. Should we do this when their parents who are negligent Muslims do not accept authentic hadiths? So if we tell a child not to listen to music, for example, then they will tell their parents, who will say that it is not haram. Or we say do not draw humans and animal faces and their parents mock this or say, "Do not brainwash my children." My nephews and nieces are sadly not taught Islam correctly at home, and their parents let them sing christmas songs, listen to music, and watch tv-shows that teach bad things and many evils that will have most likely stay with them after they reach puberty. Their parents think that hadiths that they do not agree with have been made up by people, they do not care if the hadith is authentic or not, they only care whether they like it or not. My brother does not even pray and says that he has a good heart, and he befriends the shia and support their leaders. He cannot be reasoned with because he follows his own desires. My sister on the other hand prays but is also negligent and always stressed and just follows whatever she was taught by our parents or what she sees others doing, which includes tabarruj (not wearing the hijab). Their spouses are negligent as well. I try to forbid my nephews and nieces without saying that something is haram. Instead, I say that I do not like pictures with humans or that I do not like music so they should not play music here and so on. I do not want to debate with my siblings because they do not return matters to the Quran and the Sunnah. Will I be held accountable for not telling the children that something is haram? My intention is not to withhold the truth, it is to avoid a debate with their ignorant parents who also will tell their children something else and it will confuse them if they hear two things, or they will not understand a matter and instead might think badly of Islam.


Search Fatwa 

