Question
Asalam o Alaykum!!!( Please reply to this question) I have three questions regarding same issue. I know this question has been raised by so many people and you have answered it so many times on your website and I have seen all of that. But I still have Slight confusion if you can clear that Firstly- If a person does some sin liable to Hadd or Tazir like Zina, theft,slandering someone of adultery, etc and repents and return people their rights (if he violates any) but does not get the required punishment because his sin did not reach Islamic authorities. Is that enough for that person to repent and conceal all his sin if he lives in an Islamic state? I know you will say that repentance is enough based upon all conditions of repentance fulfilled. But still I have listened to some scholars who says that repentance is not enough for these sins as Allah has prescribed a Hadd or Tazir penalty for that and the meaning of repentance for that kind of sins means application of hadd so a sinner must confess his sins to be punished. But the mainstream scholars says just repentance wipes out all sins even when you are punished. So are these scholars not educated enough on this matter or are giving wrong fatwas who are saying that without application of Hadd or Tazir, there is no forgiveness. Please clear up this confusion that is it compulsory for that person to confess or is it compulsory for the witnesses to report what sin they have seen (if there are any witnesses) so that person can be punished or just true repentance made with sincere heart is enough. What is the correct opinion of scholars? Secondly what is meant by this statement in fatwa 182875 that confessing sin should only be done when Shariah of Allah is applied. I know some cases in which a few people committed Zina and told reliable scholars from Saudi Arabia asked them to go away and repent only


Search Fatwa 

