Question
A young man proposed to me, and during the shoufa (marital meeting), I felt uncomfortable and sensed right away that he didn’t suit me. I felt suffocated around him and just couldn’t imagine myself with him. But I couldn’t express this discomfort in front of our families.I prayed and did a lot of istikhara, especially the du’a: “O Allah, choose for me and do not leave the choice to me. By Your mercy, I seek relief.” Over two weeks, the feeling of unease grew stronger. Every time someone brought up his name, I felt distressed and withdrawn. Eventually, I told my father I wasn’t comfortable marrying him. He was very supportive, may Allah preserve him, and he canceled the proposal with the man’s family.However, my mother reacted differently. She said I was rejecting a blessing and that I would never find someone like him again—that this was a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. She began to pressure me to meet him again, though I’ve made it clear I don’t want to. Still, she insisted, and now I’m overthinking and feeling guilty. I wonder if I’ve rejected a gift from Allah or gone against the teachings of the Prophet ?.But at the same time, I know I made istikhara, sought advice, and truly don’t feel at peace with this man. I’m confident in my decision, yet I still feel whispers of doubt. Am I sinful for saying no?


Search Fatwa 

