The senior
Testifying in front of US Congress, General David Petraeus warned on Tuesday that "significant" military gains from the "surge" were "fragile and reversible".
He told the Senate Armed Services Committee that the current withdrawal of five combat brigades should continue before a 45-day period of "consolidation and evaluation" is taken.
Ryan Crocker, the
Proceedings were interrupted on several occasions by heckling from anti-war protesters, one of whom shouted "bring them home", referring to US troops, before being escorted from the room.
Criticism of
General Petraeus said that after the 45-day period the
The current troop drawdown would reduce troop levels from about 158,000 to 140,000.
He also continued to criticize
"Unchecked, the special groups pose the greatest long-term threat to the viability of a democratic
Recent violence in
General Petraeus also criticized the recent Iraqi operation against Shia militias in the southern city of
Meanwhile, Crocker said that the
The move has sparked criticism from some Democrats who say the move would shift the burden of the war on to the next
"The agreement will not specify troop levels, and it will not tie the hands of the next administration," he said.
"[The next
Democratic anger
The spike in violence in
Both the White House and members of the Republican party say the "surge" successfully lessened violence and argue a pause in troop withdrawals to pre-surge levels provides the means to assess the results of the "surge".
John McCain, the presumptive Republican candidate, told the Senate Armed Services committee ahead of Petraeus's testimony on Tuesday that "much needed to be done but said it was possible to "talk with real hope and optimism about the future of Iraq and the outcome of our efforts there.''
However, several Democrats criticized Petraeus' plan to halt withdrawals, saying the surge has not yielded sufficient political progress in
Senator Carl Levin, chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, said that General Petraeus had given his chain of command "a plan which has no end to it".
And both Democratic presidential hopefuls, who were present at General Petraeus's testimony, said the current
"It might well be irresponsible to continue the policy that has not produced the results that have been promised time and time again," she said.
Meanwhile Democratic presidential hopeful Barack Obama told NBC news channel on Tuesday that "the height of irresponsibility was going in [to
"It compounds the irresponsibility if all we're doing is simply moving the goal posts."
PHOTO CAPTION
US Commander in