Question
"A" and "B" were partners in a business as per an agreement that suggests to divide the profit and loss equally between them after deducting a portion of their sponsor under whose commercial registration the business was running. Meanwhile "A" desired to withdraw from the business, because he wanted to increase the portion of the sponsor according to the valium of the profit realized, which was rejected by "B". "B" had wanted to hide the increasing of the profit from the sponsor. So "A" declared that he had withdrawn from the business. But "B" denied to give "A" his entitlements in full. Only a part of the same was given to "A". The remaining was withheld with him justifying that there was a court case against the sponsor regarding some financial commitment in which if he would file their business firm would be liable to pay for him. When the matter was disputed both agreed to appoint an arbitrator and accept his verdict whatever it may be. "A" gave "B" the choice to nominate the arbitrator eventually he accepted the person appointed by "B". Finally the arbitrator issued his verdict fixing QR 2000 for "B" considering him as a working partner and to divide the profit and loss equally between them considering "A" as a silent partner. Also he suggested to increase the portion of the sponsor. Accordingly "B" paid "A" some amount from his arrears in two installments. But after 3 months he denied to pay the balance to "A", saying that he doesn't accept the verdict of the arbitrator. After five years when "B" decided to go for Hajj he approached A with an offer of 15 thousand riyals. Then A told him if he wanted to clear himself from his financial liabilities it should be on the basis of the related account. According to the accounts checked by the arbitrator there was more than 40 thousand riyals to be paid to "A" at the date of the arbitrator's rule. However A went for Hajj paying nothing to A even the amount offered by him.
Is the stand taken by B right according to Shariah? In the event of appointing an arbitrator, would it legally be binding up on the concerned parties? Would A not be considered as a continued partner entitling the profit for following period of the verdict given by the arbitrator in addition to his previous arrears?


Search Fatwa 

